The Chief Justice is the chief judge of the Supreme Court and is the highest-ranking officer of the judiciary. A player must have at least 150 hours of total active playtime to be nominated for Chief Justice by the President. In order to assume their position after being nominated, they must be approved by a majority of the Senate.
Section 19.2 of the Constitution grants the Chief Justice the power to deliver a verdict in the case of a disagreement among the Justices.
The current Chief Justice is Aladeen22.
| Number | Chief Justice | Date confirmed (Vote) | End of tenure (Reason) | Tenure length | Nominated by | Highest ranking prior position in the judiciary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Westray | 18 August 2020 (Unknown) | 15 October 2020 (Resigned) | 58 days | xEndeavour | N/A |
| 2 | Westray | 14 April 2021 (6 - 0) | 8 January 2022 (Resigned) | 269 days | hugebob23456 | Chief Justice |
| 3 | xEndeavour | 8 January 2022 (4 - 2) | 28 April 2022 (Resigned) | 111 days | 218218Consumer | N/A |
| 4 | Wuutie | 6 June 2022 (5 - 0) | 24 September 2022 (Resigned) | 110 days | Westray | Justice |
| 5 | Krix | 7 October 2022 (3 - 2) | 13 January 2023 (Resigned) | 98 days | LilDigiVert | Judge |
| 6 | Nacholebraa | 18 January 2023 (4 - 0) | 29 May 2023 (Resigned) | 131 days | Derpy_Bird | Justice |
| 7 | MilkCrack | 18 July 2023 (6 - 0) | 17 September 2023 (Resigned) | 61 days | LilDigiVert | Justice |
| 8 | Drew_Hall | 5 November 2023 (5 - 0) | 21 February 2024 (Resigned) | 108 days | xlayzur | Justice |
| 9 | xlayzur | 6 March 2024 (4 - 0) | 6 March 2024 (Removed by Staff) | 0 days | Bezzergeezer | N/A |
| 10 | Nacholebraa | 20 March 2024 (4 - 2) | 27 April 2024 (Resigned) | 38 days | GoldBlooded | Chief Justice |
| 11 | Dartanman | 11 June 2024 (3 - 2) | 12 July 2024 (Resigned) | 31 days | GoldBlooded | Justice |
| 12 | SumoMC | 1 August 2024 (4 - 0) | 1 September 2024 (Resigned) | 31 days | Bezzergeezer | Justice |
| 13 | Aladeen22 | 12 October 2024 (3 - 2) | Current | 252 days | Bezzergeezer | Judge |
Note: Although Chief Justice Krix resigned, it was after the House had impeached him. On 23 January 2023, the Senate unanimously found him guilty on all charges.
Note: Acting chief justices are not listed.